November 13, 2026

Have Influencers Lost Touch With Reality?

By: Gabby McGillis 

As an avid social media user and shopper, some of my favorite TikTok or Instagram Reels content consists of micro and major influencers displaying new items they have received in the mail, typically in the form of a “haul”. I enjoy seeing new makeup or clothing videos from my favorite users around my same age so that I can keep up with trends and understand what is relevant in the fashion and beauty world. 

However, I am ashamed to admit that sometimes I think to myself about how I wish I could buy all the things that they have. What happens when receiving an abundance of free products and gifts becomes so normalized by influencers?

The big question is: where do we draw the line between influencers showcasing items to viewers so that they can keep up with trends versus being so unrealistic that audiences start to believe they should be living this exact same lifestyle? While there isn’t anything inherently wrong with influencers receiving gifts from brands, especially if they are promoting smaller businesses, this type of content makes me wonder how audiences are interpreting this type of overconsumption and how it is affecting consumer behaviors.  

According to a study on consumer perceptions of influencer gifting written by Psychology and Marketing and published by Wiley Online Library, although the term “influencer gifting” is used heavily in practice, this is not a fully established marketing tactic or defined in marketing research. Unlike business or corporate gifts, influencer gifts have a key third player: followers. In many cases, elaborate gifts can have negative effects on influencer trustworthiness and can undermine the influencer’s credibility. This is likely caused because followers feel that they cannot relate to an influencer when they are receiving and using an abundance of items that they themselves cannot purchase. 

When thinking about lost sense of reality among popular influencers one video that comes to mind is a “Christmas Stocking Haul” from the user @kendallmaynard25. This video includes items such as Lululemon accessories, perfumes, an Owala water bottle, Charlotte Tilbury makeup products, jewelry from Pandora, and more. In the comment section on the post, viewers noted how what Kenny received in her stocking was more than what they received for all of Christmas. Kenny is about 21 years-old and has about 2.3 million followers on TikTok; she is incredibly influential among young adult females. This video she shared is demonstrative of how many influencers have lost sense of reality in terms of consumption of materialistic items. Not only is this shown through influencer gifting, but also through influencers showcasing what they receive on a regular basis in their lives. This type of content can have strong impacts on audiences in two main ways; 1) causing influencers to lose credibility as explained by Wiley Library’s Psychology and Marketing article, and 2) causing viewers to feel as though they are doing something wrong in their life by not having as many items or experiences as influencers who live this abnormal lifestyle. 

Another key concept to consider is how this lack of reality and overconsumption from influencers leads to environmental impacts. According to Washington State University, “Influencers can impact their followers by promoting certain behaviors… “If influencers neglect environmental sustainability considerations in their unboxing videos, consumers won’t see it as a priority. 

While influencer gifting and hauls are not always negative, excessive consumption can create unrealistic expectations for younger audiences. When influencers normalize receiving an abundance of products or items, consumers may believe that this type of lavish lifestyle is something they should strive for, regardless of how unrealistic it is.

Connect with me:

My Linkedin | gabby.mcgillis7@gmail.com

Stock Image Source

9 thoughts on “Have Influencers Lost Touch With Reality?”

  1. I really enjoyed your blog post! I completely agree with you. Where do we draw the line between advertising and the unfair distribution of free products? A new angle for marketing could still be offering PR to influencers and micro-influencers, but also giving the opportunity to those who aren’t influencers to receive the same products. This could be done with either a sign-up or a raffle; nonetheless, this could allow brands to engage different audiences while still promoting their products. Regardless, I really enjoyed your blog, and I found it very interesting!

  2. It’s been interesting to see how the influencing world has come to fruition. It makes me wonder what will come of influencing in the next 50 years. Especially with authenticity being so key in virality, I wonder if influencing will ever go out of style?

  3. Great post! I think it’s interesting that influencers can lose credibility from over consumerism, while in my opinion, celebrities seem to get a free pass.

  4. Hey Gabby!
    I thought your point about influencer hauls leading to unrealistic expectations was interesting. When someone constantly posts products they receive for free, it can be easy to forget that most people would have to pay for those same products with their hard earned money. I also liked that you brought up the environmental impact, since I usually think about how this content affects spending habits but not how much waste from packages there are. I wonder if influencers would be more relatable if they were more a bit mre honest about what they actually need, not just showcasing every product they get.

  5. Hi Gabby! I really liked this post and think the topic is super interesting. I agree that most popular influencers are out of touch, or at least the content they are posting makes it seem that way. I do appreciate when I see videos of these influencers giving their PR to less fortunate or nurses, etc. I know that a lot of people enjoy them but I feel like Christmas hauls specifically are so problematic because it just encourages viewers to be envious of something they can’t have. Great post!

  6. Hi Gabby, I really liked this piece you wrote. I think this topic coming out right around when a lot of people are calling out influencers for overconsumption, losing touch with reality, and consistently “flexing” the items they receive from PR packages etc. While its not inherently a bad thing they are showing off all these things, over the past several years a level of tone deafness has been escalating across the internet. Almost like a “rich get richer poor get poorer” kind of debacle. I this is extremely relevant today because its not just videos like this where people are calling out other influencers but in various other categories.

  7. Hi Gabby!! I really enjoyed reading your post! I completely agree that influencer hauls can create unrealistic expectations, especially for younger audiences. I love watching makeup and clothing hauls, but sometimes I catch myself wanting things I don’t even need just because I saw an influencer using them. I think it’s easy to forget that a lot of these influencers get products for free, while their followers are actually spending money to keep up with the trends. I also thought your point about the environmental impact was interesting because that’s not something I usually think about when watching hauls. I think influencers should be more mindful of what they’re promoting and how it can affect their audience.

  8. The tittle on this blog immediately drew me in, because it’s something I’ve asked myself. I was surprised to find out that too many elaborate gifts can have a negative effect on the influencer’s trustworthiness and credibility, although it makes sense because it draws the line on relatability between the influencer and it’s followers. Awesome post and great topic. I think this will be talked about more as other people take on Influencing as a career.

  9. This post brings up a great discussion about overconsumption and materialism. I, too, find myself wrapped up in influencer trends and the hyper-consumerism of it all. And I realize that when I am in this state of mind, I feel awful and end up not even buying anything because I am so overwhelmed by the oversaturation of products and my lack of money. I think that influencers should consider these things when sharing all of the free things that they get and deliver the message that “THIS IS NOT NORMAL.”

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.